Protect
research even if second rate colleges have to close, says UCL head
The government should slash
student places at "pile it high, sell it cheap" universities – even
if it means some being forced to close – to protect Britain's "world
class" research institutions, the head of University College London has
said.
Speaking ahead of a speech on
Thursday by the business secretary, Vince Cable, in which the government is
expected to outline plans to cut costs in higher education, UCL's Malcolm Grant
said elite universities feared the government was poised to cut research
funding.
Such a move could
"decimate Britain's global competitiveness in research", Grant told
the Guardian, arguing that there is a "direct human benefit" in areas
such as cancer and Parkinson's disease from research-intensive universities.
Grant, provost of UCL – rated
fourth best university in the world after Harvard, Cambridge and Yale – said:
"The biggest risk to the big research universities is a cut in funding for
research, if that was done without proper identification of excellence then it
would decimate Britain's global competitiveness in research."
As applications for
university places continue to soar – they hit a record high for the fourth year
in a row – the government is under intense pressure not to impose further cuts
on the numbers of students.
Cuts in teaching budgets
would affect all universities and risk protest from the families of bright
children who were denied places. But cutting research funding would hit elite
universities disproportionately; last year UCL received nearly £69m from the
government for teaching compared with £104m for research.
Grant said: "The
politics of reducing total student numbers is very difficult, if it then leads
to the conclusion that there should be fewer universities. There will be
political pressure to keep open universities at the teaching-only end of the
spectrum by taking resources away from the world-class research
universities."
David Willetts, the
universities secretary, has hinted that students could soon be forced to pay
higher tuition fees, warning that the cost of degree courses was a "burden
on the taxpayer" that had to be tackled.
But in return, universities
will come under pressure to improve the quality of their teaching and ensure
that students are prepared to enter a tough jobs market.
Last month, Willetts told the
Guardian: "The system doesn't contain strong incentives for universities
to focus on teaching and the student experience as opposed to research."
Grant urged the government to
consider reducing student numbers if that was the price of maintaining
Britain's research heritage. "I think it's an avoidable consequence if
politicians are prepared to revisit the question of student numbers," he
said.
UCL researchers work on
conditions ranging from cardiovascular disease to MRSA; an ex-PhD student,
Charles Kao, won the Nobel prize for physics in 2009 for work on fibre-optic
communications.
Grant said: "If you talk
about research, people don't realise what huge human benefit, direct human
benefit, comes from it. We've got a major cancer unit, we've got people working
on Parkinson's, we've had the award of a Nobel prize."
Grant said differences
between universities were not reflected in the fact that all of them charged
the same tuition fees. This masked the fact that elite universities offered a
far richer experience, he said
"Universities vary quite
a lot in the cost of their teaching, but you can't vary the price. Much of it
depends on whether you're a research institution, whether you've got libraries
or 'pile it high and sell it cheap' – these differences aren't reflected in the
funding model."
The elite Russell group of
universities are keen to allow institutions to set their own fees – they have
argued in their submission to Lord Browne's review of fees that students who
stand to gain the most should pay the most.
Grant said that if the
government favoured an increase in tuition fees, the cost of a UCL degree could
rise towards the amount charged to a foreign student.
According to next year's fees
schedule, an arts degree such as ancient history will cost £12,770 for an
overseas student while medicine will cost £24,940.
He said, however, that fees
charged to domestic students would always be lower than those to foreign
students because of the taxpayer subsidy – and there would not be a variable
cost by subject to avoid deterring applicants for the sciences, which cost more
to teach.
Grant said he aspired to the
Yale model, in which students are charged a headline fee of $51,000 (£34,000),
but only half of them pay the full amount. However, British universities lack
the generous endowments make the American system of bursaries possible. Britain
is "light years" away from that, he said.
Pam Tatlow, chief executive
of million+, which represents many of Britain's new universities, said the UCL
head's view "fails to recognise that our higher education sector must
deliver results for universities, students, the UK economy and society rather
than just a handful of vested interests." He urged the government to
maintain the number of student places: "Coalition ministers would be extremely
short-sighted if they paid any attention to these suggestions and supported a
very small number of universities at the expense of providing places for the
record numbers of applicants hoping to secure a place at university in this or
future years. They would also be breaking the commitment to social mobility
made in their coalition agreement only a few weeks ago."
To help prepare students for
a demanding global jobs market, UCL is planning to introduce a combined honours
degree in arts and sciences. The interdisciplinary degrees will include
optional modules from across the range of subjects in science, culture and
health. Such degrees are regarded as challenging and aimed at the most able
students.
A government spokesman said
the business secretary's speech had not been finalised. However, Cable is
expected to say costs could be reduced by separating teaching from examining,
so that new institutions would be allowed to teach students for degrees that
would be awarded by more prestigious universities. He is keen to encourage the
growth of private universities. He has also agreed that Labour's plan for half
the population to go to university should be scrapped.
Source: Guardian.co.uk