Vince Cable,
the Business Secretary who is responsible for universities, will say in a
keynote speech tomorrow that the present system of higher education must
undergo radical changes to enable the Government to balance the nation's books.
Mr Cable accepts that universities, which account for about half of his
£19bn-a-year budget, cannot be immune from the cuts. He believes that it is
difficult to justify courses with tuition of six or seven hours a week. While
two-year degrees would transform the university experience for thousands of
undergraduates, Mr Cable believes that many would welcome three-year courses
being condensed to reduce their tuition fees – and their debts.
The Liberal
Democrat MP also wants more students to live at home, attending lectures at a
local university while taking their degree at one much further afield. He says
the need for savings cannot be achieved by "salami-slicing" and will
require changes in the way higher education is provided – a signal that he will
allow an expansion of private universities, some of which could provide the "close-to-home"
lectures on behalf of the institutions awarding degrees. He also wants a debate
about student support and numbers, amid signs that Labour's target of raising
the number of people in higher education from 43 to 50 per cent will be
abandoned.
Mr Cable's ideas
will be among his department's options for spending cuts to be submitted to the
Treasury by the end of this week. He will meet the Chancellor George Osborne's
demand for 25 per cent cuts over four years, with other proposals for further
reductions on top of that. Most departments have been asked to draw up plans
for two scenarios – a 25 and 40 per cent reduction in their budgets.
However, Mr
Cable will warn the Treasury that some of his budget – such as research funding
for new industries and products – should be protected to ensure the Government
has a "growth strategy." Ministerial allies insist that Mr Cable is
not "playing games" by proposing politically unacceptable cuts and
recalled that he was a "deficit hawk" before the May election. One
said: "He is a team player. He will do his bit. There are hard choices to
be made and university funding will be among them. He wants the Treasury and
the Cabinet to know what would be involved."
Mr Cable
wants to encourage more variable tuition fees. He believes that lifting the
£3,225-a-year cap on fees – likely to be recommended this autumn in a review by
Lord Browne of Madingley, the former BP chief executive – will not solve the
funding crisis as it would raise public spending as the budget for student
loans would increase.
Although Lord
Mandelson, Business Secretary in the previous government, called for more
two-year courses, he envisaged them being offered for a limited number of
universities and courses. If adopted, Mr Cable's plan would range far wider.
Dr Terence
Kealey, vice-chancellor of the private Buckingham University, the first in the
UK to offer a standard two-year academic degree, said: "Many more people
are suited to two-year courses than realise it. In future, instead of a gap
year, people may work for two years and then take a two-year degree when they
are a bit older. The advantage is that they are earning in year three. We
should allow people to choose what they want. But two years is a very cost-effective
option."
He cited new
research by the University of Staffordshire suggesting that two-year students
achieved an average grade increase of 0.75 of a point, turning a 2:2 degree
into a 2:1. "The normal argument for a three-year degree is that you need
a long, four-month summer break for deep thoughts. No other human activity
requires that. On a two-year course at Buckingham, you still have 12 weeks
holiday a year and you don't lose your train of thought," he said.
But Dr Wendy
Piatt, director general of the 20-strong Russell Group of universities, said:
"Two-year accelerated degrees ... are unlikely to work well for many of
the courses offered by Russell Group universities, which are academically
intensive and in many cases laboratory-based. The research-led learning at
Russell Group institutions takes place in an environment where leading academic
staff are engaged in both research and teaching and much of this activity takes
places during the 'holiday' periods."
Source:
Independent.co.uk